Monday, March 3, 2014

Week 8: Derek Garcia - Prison as Ghetto; Ghetto as Prison - Both as a Money Maker


In my search for further information regarding the linkages between the ghetto and the prison industrial complex, as explained in depth by Loic Wacquant in Deadly Symbiosis: When Ghetto and Prison Meet and Mesh, I found the above web page that highlights some statistics and observations that Wacquant highlights in another one of his works, Prisons of Poverty.
The following is a list of these, per the website:
·         Putting people in jail in the United States has become the nation's "largest program for the poor." Federal, state and local corrections administrations employ almost three-quarters of a million people. This makes it America's "fourth largest employer, behind Wal-Mart ... and just ahead of General Motors."
·         Republican calls for "small government" do not apply to prisons --- and the annual payroll for corrections institutions now exceeds $10,000,000,000.
·         One of the great provokers of the "war on crime" is low-cost television shows, also known as "drive-by journalism." There are America's Most Wanted, Unsolved Mysteries, and Cops which feed the public's ever-mounting fear of crime, despite the facts; which are:
o    According to FBI Uniform Crime Statistics, crime rates in the United States have actually continued to drop, during the same time period that ABC, NBC, and CBS have quadrupled the number of crime stories on their evening news programs: "typically five stories per evening ... 200% more than even ten years ago."
o    The antidrug policy of government acts as "spear and screen" for a war "against persons perceived as the least useful and potentially most dangerous parts of the population: the jobless, the homeless, the paperless immigrants, beggars, vagrants and other social rejects."
·         African-Americans represent 13 percent of consumers of drugs, about the same figure --- proportionally --- as for whites. But "in ten states, black men are twenty-five times more likely than white men to be sent to prison on a narcotics charge." In Illinois, minorities make up "70 percent of the drug arrestees and 86 percent of those admitted to state prison.
I use the term ‘prison industrial complex’ in this context because the book’s summary describes Wacquant’s assertion that these bullet points exist as such, not because of increasing crime rates, but more so because of the profitability targets of the privatized companies that operate many prisons.Wacquant points out that one of these companies, Corrections Corporation of Americas (CCA), had a stock appreciation of 746% in “a recent 3-year period”.  By any industry standard, this is a phenomenal increase in profitability and stockholders must’ve been ecstatic with their return on investment.  It’s a fair assumption that executive bonuses were very healthy as well.
It’s interesting to me that, although different in form, poor folks of color, especially blacks, are still commoditized; however, instead of being slave or low-wage workers, as in the past, they are now literally worth more money when they (we) are locked up.
With so many people (still) getting rich off of the backs of the oppressed, how will we ever change the vicious cycle of the prison-ghetto phenomenon?  Will we be able to get legislation past politicians who only serve one master – the rich corporate money-making machines who finance their campaigns?

Does Probation for Profit Criminalize Poverty?

http://www.npr.org/2014/02/07/273041871/does-probation-for-profit-criminalize-poverty


    I found this NPR interview Chris Albin-Lackey who is a researcher for the Human Rights Watch. The interview brings up a new movement in Mississippi, Georgia and Alabama that puts you at risk for jail time and probation if you can not pay your fines for small misdemeanor offenses and sometimes even speeding tickets.
    The interview shows us how this kind of private probation is another way in which poverty can be an inescapable hole. For the people who can not pay their fine in whole at the time of their court date, a probation period is issued to give them time to pay off the fine. However, the private companies that monitor the probation and the fines are able to profit off of these fines. The longer it takes an offender to pay off their fine the more money they end up paying for the fine. In other words the poor pay a higher cost for their fine than the wealthier who are guilty of the exact same crime.
    Even scarier is the fact that jail time is too often the outcome for the citizens who can not afford to pay their fine in time. In the interview they state that jailing someone for not being able to pay a fine is unconstitutional. However, the problem with this is is that the offenders are usually not aware of their own rights. Statistics show that education levels are much lower in impoverished communities. We learn our rights in school and most of the impoverished community did not have have the opportunity to learn their own rights.  So when you give someone who is unaware of their rights the choice of either paying their fines or going to jail even though they can not afford to pay their fines they of course are going to choose the fine. Thus throwing them into a long ordeal of overpaying for a small offense only because they are unaware that they are being threatened with false pretense.
    The Probation for Profit sector is using poor citizens who they know can not defend themselves or afford high ticket prices, to make money for their own pockets. This is just one example of how our society is criminalizing poverty.

Ghetto First Lady?

Following on the heels of Dr. Holmes, I noticed the ghetto label being thrown at the First Lady, in my opinion, too often.  Take this picture for instance:

The internet had a field day with this!  I came across this photo on a site called reddit titled, "No matter who you are, when your wife says switch seats, you switch seats."  People can't handle an assertive woman, especially if she is Black or Latina. What is interesting about this photo, and all photos surrounding the first lady, is that this makes her an angry Black woman which is then read as a Ghetto Black Woman. This is reminiscent of the one drop rule:  one drop of ghetto blood in you then you are ghetto. 


Thinking back to the documentary, some folks had to hide the fact that they were from the projects because of negative assumptions. I argue that these assumptions are made about all Black people and we have to do what we can to show the world that we are not associated with the ghetto or ghetto culture. 




Evolution of Mom Dancing!


Sophia Surage
RCP Week 8
Blog 2

“Evolution of Mom Dancing” Within Symbolic Grasp of “Ghetto”



            Approximately one year ago, First Lady Michelle Obama participated in a light-hearted dance skit along side Jimmy Fallon (dressed in drag) on The Tonight Show. The skit is a goofy promotion of Mrs. Obama’s “Let’s Move” campaign aimed to address child obesity by encouraging parents and their children to get active together. The video is titled “Evolution of the mom dance” and consists of Fallon and Obama doing a run through of all of the “mom” dances including “the sprinkler” “the shopping cart” “just the hand part of single ladies” etc. Overall the spirit of the skit is fun and goofy and shows that dancing is fun no matter how funny you look while doing it.
            The YouTube comments section for the video of the performance is still very active with what appear to be pretty polarized opinions about Mrs. Obama. While many comments capture the light hearted tone of the skit and feature comments like “Go Michelle!” and “Our first Lady is the coolest” others are incredibly racist and revealing of the painful historical portrayals of black female sexuality that continue to be levied against black womanhood. The comments also tellingly reveal the how ghettoization is still connected to blackness within the American mainstream psyche. Specifically the ways in which the racist comments attack Michelle Obama’s (and black women in general) sexuality are by criminalizing her behavior and calling it “ghetto”. Some comments even specifically accuse Michelle Obama of bringing the ghetto into the white house, and disgracing the elegant role of first lady.
            I focus on the comments section for this post not because I am a masochist, nor because I want to provide any more of a platform for the sheer ignorance and racism that some people chose to express, but to reflect upon how blackness, gender, ghettoization, and criminology function in our current moment. Several of the comments express concern that Michelle Obama’s dancing, despite the fact that the video innocently depicts “the Evolution of Mom dancing”, is somehow disgracing the high honor of being a classy/dignified first lady. Other comments have a transphobic and racist undertone in claiming that Michelle Obama, “Looks like a man” which falls into a long history of hyper-masculinizing black women and theoretically barring them from definitions of what constitutions graceful, proper, pure femininity. A few comments refer directly and or subtly to ghettos. B2-12’s comment about Michelle Obama’s “weave” pokes fun at black female beauty practices, and taps into stereotypes about hairstyles that are described as “ghetto” and a reflection of a woman’s presumed lack of social status and/or classiness.
            In “Punishment & Society Deadly Symbioses: When Ghetto and Prison Meet and Mesh” Loic Wacquant points to the ideological ties between how ghettos function as “ethnoracial prisons” and how they function alongside actual prison spaces that are racialized.  Furthermore, Wacquant illustrates how blackness continues to be criminalized even outside of the spatialized perameters of inner city ghettos. Wacquant writes: “Today’s black bourgeoisie still lives under strict segregation and its life chances continue to be curtailed by its geographic and symbolic contiguity with the African-American (sub)proletariat (Patillo-McCoy, 1990)” (Wacquant, 104). Nonetheless, it has gained considerable physical distance from the heart of the ghetto by establishing satellite black neighborhoods at its periphery inside the city and in the suburbs” (Wacquant, 104). If inner city ghettos have historically been used to concentrate, contain, and police people of color in order to systematically push them into prisons, then the idea of “ghetto” continues to be used symbolically to criminalize and police black behavior, especially when it is perceived to be out of place. Racist perceptions of Michelle Obama in this skit attack her at the core of her femininity, through critiques of her hair, and her lack of “elegance”. These comments accuse Mrs. Obama of failing to perform the role of first lady properly by being too “ghetto”. A white woman would mostly likely never be accused of being “ghetto” if she were to step outside of the boundaries of proper femininity although she may be slut-shamed, or called a “commoner”. Calling Michelle Obama ghetto is an attack specific to race and class, casting her as deviant and dangerous because it is presumed that her blackness and blackness in general belong in spaces other than the white house. Finally, the fact that a black woman is serving as first lady and the  that she is sparking anxieties that her blackness will somehow track a trail of “ghetto” into America’s “pristine” core reflects the ways in which ghettos operate as a tool for criminalizing blackness in and of itself.
Several comments from the Youtube Page are featured below:
This is really embarrassing.  First Lady Jackie Kennedy wouldn't have been the BUTT of a joke on TV.  MO should act more dignified, instead of like a clown.  That's Obozo's job
She is definitely not a pretty woman . But this is the best I have ever seen her look. She is usually very embittered looking and reminds me of a "hands on the hip" ..."angry Black woman".
She looks like an ape.
Fallon looks more like a woman than Michelle.
does Saturday Night Live have to get special permits to do an act with a Bonobo ?
Reply  · 
This is an embarrassment to the elegant role of First Lady..Thomas Wickett1 week ago (edited) How much more can a president and a first lady denigrate the office of the presidency? It's no wonder that we're the joke of not just the free world but of the entire world.            
There goes the neighborhood.. i remember when a presidency had a little bit of .. i don't know.. class.. regalness.. no wonder other countries laugh at us.. the presidency has turned.. ghetto.. sigh
jimmys wig looks just as real as her weave.
           

Week 8: School to Prison Pipeline: Another Form of Incarceration

http://theuptake.org/2014/02/27/school-to-prison-pipeline-sparks-protest-school-walkout/

            This week, when trying to better understand the idea of criminalizing the poor and the idea of turning the ghetto into a prison and the prison into a ghetto, I found the “School to Prison Pipeline” movement very relevant. In today’s society, students of color are being suspended for first time offenses or smaller offenses that white students might only get a slap on the hand for. As the article above states, “…youth of color and low-income youth ‘were stigmatized by teachers’” (Regan, 2014).  This article was a shocking read and when I looked at the date and saw that this is from only a week ago, it made me sick. Just as housing projects such as Pruitt Igoe created a prison like atmosphere that stigmatized and criminalized based on skin color, schools even today are doing the same thing. As the prison and ghetto are linked by a triple relationship of functional equivalency, structural homology, and culture fusion, one can argue that school systems have these three characteristics as well.

            Just as people in the housing projects were treated as less than human, students of color in the schooling system are treated as second-class citizens.  Once students are suspended they are ever more likely to find crime or become homeless because they don’t have school keeping them straight. It is a constant worry for these kids that they will be unfairly suspended for something that should require counseling or detention.  One girl in the article talks about how she was put directly into a truancy intervention program for missing school while she was very ill.  She is being labeled because of her skin color. It is a rule that if you miss more than seven days (unexcused) you can be put into juvenile court or put on probation. Just as the ghetto is being turned into a prison system, so are the schools. How is a student supposed to get anywhere if they can’t even get through high school? It is no wonder why African Americans are over represented in the prison system when they are more frequently kicked out of high school for minor/first time offenses. If you can’t make a living because you don’t have a high school diploma, you most likely will make your living through crime.

"Tower in the Park" Originated in the Ivory Tower

How much can architecture dictate the culture of a place? The whole idea behind the "Tower in the Park" model that Pruitt-Igoe followed originated from French architects and city planners in the 1920's who envisioned a "radiant city" that would reunite humans with a well ordered environment. The very placement of buildings was supposed to dictate orderly, "civilized" interactions between their residents. Yet the people who design these projects rarely live in them (the architect for Pruitt-Igoe also designed the World Trade Center towers in New York... grim comparison) and experience the consequences of their design on a personal basis.
Radiant City Design
Design features like tall, skinny towers with just one easily controlled entry point and easily surveillance of police arrival have been repeatedly blamed (along with their architects) for the failure of 'Tower in the Park" public housing projects. But this seems like a disastrously oversimplified explanation, especially because similar projects in thriving cities, where the towers have been integrated into the fabric of the public transportation system, have flourished. 

I guess the question I'm trying to ask in this blog post is, "who should have the authority to design homes (and prisons) with the goal of improving peoples' material realities, and how is this knowledge generated?." It seems like a huge problem that architects who dream up these plans will never have to live in them. The license to design also seems to be predicated on some super natural (institutionally-controlled) ability to assess "trends" in crime and housing and labor markets, and design to fit those needs. With Pruitt-Igoe, as with many other projects and prisons, we saw an obvious and grave miscalculation of population growth. 

On the other hand, the idea that nobody knows better how to design their home than the home-dweller themselves is still far fetched in the public imagination.  Lawmakers and voters (if we are to imagine that they and not the real-estate developers have the real power) are reluctant to trust anybody, really, with the care and decision making regarding their own dwelling. This is the very premise of public housing. There are a small sect of urban planners using "participatory planning" methods and *gasp* asking the community members what they'd like before embarking on a design project. But this idea is still fringe. 

So I went fishing about the internet for an compromise, and came up with a young Harvard architect who is proposing a new design for prison, not a housing project, that while firmly reformist, is pretty radical for what it is. 

http://www.archdaily.com/464371/a-radical-new-approach-to-prison-design/

This architect, bread in one of the US's finest institutions, once again believes that design can dictate cultural outcome, and if this project ever comes to fruition (which seems unlikely, honestly) I wonder if we should keep out hopes in check for the transformative potential of design. 

Sunday, March 2, 2014

Insular Segregation


If we are to accept Wacquant’s argument that places like Pruitt-Igoe are part of the architecture of “the ghetto” as “prison” (and vice versa) then the ghetto obtains a representation of Foucault’s Panopticon with intentions of maximizing black imprisonment for capital. Wacquant’s argument exposes the intimate link between “the ghetto” and “the prison” as fraternal twins (not identical). In every aspect of “the ghetto” there is a policing eye always fixed on the habitants’ actions. 

Architecturally, public housing projects often resemble prisons with “’random searches, segregation, curfews, and resident counts – all familiar procedures of efficient prison management’” (107 (Miller, 1997: 101). With families on welfare, the ‘necessity’ for government intervention is present. Management of financials, children, and lifestyle are taken on by the state. In this way the state enforces, with a seemingly hidden eye, “the disciplining of women from the lower class and caste [which] continues to operate primarily through the agencies of the social arm of the American state (namely, welfare and workfare)” (Note 1, p. 121). The state, just as in the Pruitt-Igoe case seems to lurk about so much so that parents educate their children on how to react when the state comes to ‘inspect’ (Freidrichs). Similarly the education systems that are in “the ghettos” operate “in the manner of institutions of confinement whose primary mission is not to educate but to ensure ‘custody and control’” (108). With this notion, Wacquant’s argument exposes that the future, the children of people (especially of color) who live in “the ghettos” lack a mainstreamed social education and are instead indoctrinated into a penal system. Instead of trained teachers, equipment, operational bathroom facilities, and textbooks schools in such areas fund “for more weapon scanners, cameras, emergency telephones, sign-in desks, and security personnel, whose duty is to repel unwanted intruders from the outside and hem students inside the school’s walls” (108). The dearth of rudimentary education for children in “the ghettos” and the immersion into a world of possibility of violence, being keenly watched, and lack of facility mirror the Panopticon. 

The economic and class aspects are interwoven in Wacquant’s theses as they are irrevocable from the complex problems surrounding the racialization of criminality, punishment, and penal systems in America. Too, the maximization of black labor for capital has been transfigured into a different type of labor for capital. “Denied access to valued cultural capital” (119), being subject to reimbursement to prisons, exclusion “from social redistribution and public aid” (119), (et al) promote an enclosed, circular economy between the penal system and minorities that live in “the ghettos”. The denial of opportunity for grants to educate one’s self, to pay off loans, to work, to eat, to shelter one’s self creates an insulated economy between “the ghettos” and “prisons” because this denied access excluded such people from society.